By virtue of the fact that it is not alive, it is impossible for the product to be "healthy." The dispute should be over whether it is healthful.
Meh, that particular grammatical ship has sailed.
But yeah, it's water with flavoring and coloring. It's no better for you than Crystal Light, which is low-calorie, but full of artificial nastiness that isn't exactly good for you.
I'll be happy when we can buy red potions to heal our bodies, green potions to heal our minds, and blue potions to heal both. Those would be awe to the some.
They will be sold by travelling merchants and old ladies. Or travelling old lady merchants. Just because.
I'll be happy when I dont' have to buy potions, and can just draw symbols on the ground and say "Narokath Santak Chattur'gha!" and be totally healed of any ailment or injury. And can you imagine what Xel'lotath-aligned healing spells would do for the state of mental-health care in the US?