They certainly have a lot of knowledge, but true wisdom comes from Christ and life experience, not just memorizing the pages of a book and repeating it ad infinitum.
If My Little Pony Guy starts spouting Bible verses, he'll fit right in. So far, he's basically hitting all of the checkmarks:
Takes Left Behind seriously.
Thinks his instructors don't "really think for themselves."
Scoffs at any religion other than Christianity.
Thinks Jesus talks back to him.