here's an idea: using the dungeons and dragons alignment system
available here, name a poster of your choice and their alignment.
i don't want this to degenerate into a free for all, so please state your reasons, and the no bitching rule is in full effect. basically, based on the poster's previous messages, evaluate their alignment using wikipedia's guidelines.
(mods, please feel free to nail this game if you feel it'll become a bitchfest)
i'll start it off with naming PostHumanHeresy as Chaotic Neutral, since he's pretty consistent in calling for freedom on most things, even reprehensible ones, although the discussion about his views on Anonymous nailed it for me. not a bad guy, just very strict on freedom.
remember, it's a game, no sore losers, no bitching, just good, clean fun