Not that it matters but Paranal's example is also wrong. If Antifa is a specific subset of those against fascism then all antifa are by definition against fascism.
So rather than saying 'you may as well say France is a Republic so all people who live in republics must be French', Paranal is saying France can't be a Republic because there are other Republics.
But we all know what our g.i.r.l. paranal is saying is "there are good people on both sides", "I feel triggered by media which has people attacking Nazi's", "Wolfenstein just lost a customer", "Sieg - wait who let that camera in here"